“Why do I have to study this stupid cell
biology? I’ll never use this stuff. I want to be a
zookeeper!” I hear it at least once a semester, students
moaning about the required coursework for a biology
degree. They don’t realize that the skills they’re
learning might genuinely prove useful in later life—no
matter what field of biology they enter. It’s true that
not everyone runs around everyday calculating the grams
of NaCl needed to prepare one liter of a molar solution,
but strong math skills can come in handy. Not being able
to calculate the appropriate number of suppositories
needed to treat a constipated cougar, based on dose per
pound of body weight, could be problematic for both you
and the cougar!
Some (OK, many students) suggest that we
over-emphasize memorization of pathways and processes
like signal transduction or transcription and
translation. Details of the epidermal growth
factor-stimulated, Ras-mediated signaling pathway and
subsequent induction of gene expression may seem
irrelevant to those not planning to work in a biomedical
research laboratory. But realizing that by knocking over
the first domino, you cause a cascade of interconnected,
downstream effects and can predict what would happen if
one of the steps were blocked or inadvertently
activated—these are all general concepts that apply in
“real life.” Put two rabbits together in a cage, and a
year later your exhibit hall is overrun with bunnies. If
you want to be the first to successfully breed the
endangered Colorado cougar in captivity, you’d better be
sure that you’re pairing a male with female and not
another male.
Others imply that we spend too much time
training students in research methods. Were the
appropriate positive and negative controls included? Are
there enough data points to see a statistically
significant, reproducible response? Most, they argue,
won’t pursue careers where research forms the core of
their work. But the skills of deductive reasoning, based
on careful observation and analyses, are applicable
outside of research settings. If adding more substrate
doesn’t increase the reaction rate, what can be
concluded about the velocity of the enzyme? Too arcane?
How about this: The delivery man can’t find room in the
supply shed to store this month’s load of cougar chow.
Recently, you’ve noticed that several of your prized
peacocks are missing. And your newly hired animal care
assistant, Aiden, has been despondent since his
girlfriend dumped him via Facebook. Based on these
observations, what’s your hypothesis, and how will you
test it?
We need to help students see that
attention to detail is a critical, transferable talent.
Our laboratory manual describes in detail how to prepare
a manuscript-style lab report. Yes, the figure legend
goes on a separate page. No, you should not give your
graphs titles. Yes, each journal specifies its reference
style. Does it really matter whether you submit yours as
a pdf file or a Word document? Only if you’re applying
for a job, and the application requires a pdf file
format. If the deadline for submission is Friday at 5
pm, it doesn’t matter if your Internet connection went
down at 4:58 pm because of a lightning bolt. Plenty of
well-qualified others got their pdf file applications in
on time.
So, what about my training and career
path? Where have my 24 semesters of biology, 10 of
chemistry, 3 of calculus, and 2 of physics gotten me? As
I juggle my Arabidopsis plants, C. elegans plates, and
E. coli cultures in the lab, with the students in my
classes, and my family and pets at home—I feel as if I’m
running a zoo!
Back to Academic Life Page